Monday, March 31, 2014


Nashoba, Shakers, Mormons, or Onieda – Which Do You Choose?

By: Allyson Wiggs

Throughout the late 18th and 19th century there was a huge push for perfection in a person’s spiritual life. This push was caused by the Second Great Awakening. As a result of this utopian communities were formed. These communities set a standard of living for the people who decided to join them. There were four main communities: Nashoba, Shakers, Mormons, and Oneida. Each of these communities had a leader, a set of ideals, and a reason as to why the community failed. Many of the ideals were based around spiritual preferences. Some of the communities were very conservative on the rules while others were more liberal.[1] Although all of these communities were very different from our society today, there is only one community that I personally would ever want to live in.




            The Nashoba Community is the community that I share the most ideals with and the one that I believe I would survive the best in. It was founded by Frances Wright. Frances Wright was very different than many women during this time period and definitely stood out. Wright was born and grew up in Scotland, but when she visited America she enjoyed everything about it and had her own opinions on some of the things going on. For example, she visited when religion was very important and slavery was going on. These were two things she felt strongly against. Wright was a free thinker who felt like she should control her own beliefs and that a religion should not.[2] She also believed that slavery should not be in place. Wright attempted to fix some of these issues in the Nashoba Community. [3]



            This utopian community was known as “free lovers” because of their ideals on the way that the world should work. Two of the main issues the Nashoba Community dealt with was slavery and sexual relations. Since the members did not believe in slavery, they allowed the slaves to buy freedom so that they could live in emancipation settlements. They also determined that people should have sexual relations with another person only if they loved them which meant they did not have to be married. This concept went against many religious beliefs, but was allowed in this community. Although this community seems to have a very modern approach on different views, it no longer exists in today’s society. This community ended because of a controversy over slaves. While some slaves were free, some slaves were not because they could not afford to purchase freedom. This controversy ended the community. [4]



            Overall, I believe that I would want to live in the Nashoba Community most because it seems like the community with the closest ideals as we have today. In today’s society, we have a very liberal view on most things. We are very opposed to slavery just as they were and many people do not follow strictly to their religion. In my opinion, I agree with Wright’s free spirit and believe that people should make their own decisions for the most part. If the Nashoba Community was never started, it makes me wonder what today’s society may be like. I wonder if anyone would have realized that slavery is cruel and if there is a possibility we may have it today. I also wonder if people would still follow strictly to their religion. In some ways this may be better for people, but others may feel as if it is a burden to them. In general, this community really opened some people’s eyes to a different and more liberal way of life that may have never been discovered otherwise.



[1] Moore, Crystal. “Utopian Communities in Victorian America.” Lecture, History of Sexuality in America, UNCC. Charlotte, North Carolina.  March 3, 2014.
[2] “"The Cause of Human Improvement": Frances Wright and the Nashoba Community,” last modified 2011, http://www.ucs.louisiana.edu/~lxm8207/FannyWright.html.
[3] “Revisiting Nashoba: Slavery, Utopia, and Frances Wright in America, 1818–1826,” last modified 2014, http://alh.oxfordjournals.org/content/17/3/438.short.
[4] Moore, Crystal. “Utopian Communities in Victorian America.” Lecture, History of Sexuality in America, UNCC. Charlotte, North Carolina.  March 3, 2014.

No comments:

Post a Comment